Roofing

    State Farm's Oklahoma Roof Settlement: What Roofers Should Do With Denied-Claim Leads

    State Farm will reopen Oklahoma wind and hail roof claims closed without payment from 2021 to 2025. Here is which leads to pull and what a roofer can say.

    Sonny Round, Co-Founder — Tailwinds Ops

    Key Takeaways

    • State Farm agreed to $35 million in consumer restitution, $10 million for Strengthen Oklahoma Homes and $2.86 million in fines and exam expenses, $47.86 million in total, per the Oklahoma Insurance Department.
    • The review covers Oklahoma wind and hail roof claims with a date of loss from January 1, 2021 through December 31, 2025 that were closed without payment, including partial payments and under-deductible decisions.
    • The settlement agreement requires State Farm to send written notice to eligible homeowners before December 31, 2026. Homeowners then have 180 days to opt in.
    • A 2010 Oklahoma Insurance Department bulletin says a roofer needs a public adjuster license to negotiate a claim, but may give the homeowner a repair estimate to submit.
    • At the 2% to 5% response rate we've found on reactivation campaigns, 300 denied-claim estimates produce roughly 6 to 15 replies.

    If you roof in Oklahoma, your CRM has a folder of jobs that died the same way. You inspected, you wrote the estimate, State Farm closed the claim, and the homeowner decided they couldn't pay out of pocket. Some of those homeowners are about to get a letter offering a second look at that claim.

    That letter gives you a reason to get back in touch. Working the claim for them stays off-limits. This playbook covers which leads to pull, what the settlement says, and where the line sits between a roofer and an adjuster in Oklahoma.

    What did the State Farm Oklahoma settlement cover?

    The Oklahoma Insurance Department announced a $47.86 million settlement with State Farm over residential wind and hail roof claims. State Farm put up $35 million for consumer restitution, $10 million for the Strengthen Oklahoma Homes program, and $2.86 million in fines and examination expenses. Eligible homeowners can ask an independent administrator to review their old claim.

    Two caveats belong in any conversation about it. The settlement agreement says State Farm "disputes the Examination Report's findings and conclusions and denies any violation of law or wrongdoing." The program also applies only to Oklahoma homeowners. A denied State Farm claim in Kansas or Texas is not part of it.

    The $35 million is a floor. The agreement says the parties will agree in good faith on more money if claims need it. The $10 million goes to the state's Strengthen Oklahoma Homes fund, which is separate from the claim review.

    Which homeowners are eligible for the second review?

    Homeowners with a State Farm policy in Oklahoma whose wind or hail roof claim had a date of loss between January 1, 2021 and December 31, 2025 and was closed without payment. The OID page says that includes homeowners who got a partial payment or whose damage was judged to be under the deductible.

    Closed without payment, as the settlement agreement defines it, covers claims denied because the damage fell below the deductible, because no covered peril or an uninsured cause was found, because no damage was found, or because of a policy-condition violation. The OID treats partial payments as eligible too.

    The agreement excludes claims already resolved by settlement or final judgment on the same roof loss, and claims the homeowner withdrew before State Farm decided. Homeowners suing over a claim can join only if they dismiss the suit with prejudice. Anyone who accepts a payment signs a release of all claims against State Farm, and any payment is limited to the amount above the deductible and within policy limits.

    That release matters. A homeowner weighing a lawsuit against an opt-in should be talking to an attorney, not their roofer. If one asks you which to choose, tell them that.

    When will homeowners hear from State Farm?

    The agreement requires State Farm to send written notice to each eligible homeowner before December 31, 2026. The opt-in period runs 180 days from that notice. The claim administrator sends a reminder 30 days before it closes. The OID's public page says more details on timing will follow, so check it before you quote a date.

    Opting in takes a short form: name, contact details, property address, the claim, and a brief reason the homeowner believes more payment is due. Supporting documents are not required to opt in. The OID's review steps do tell homeowners they can submit receipts or professional inspections, and that "Payment is not guaranteed."

    The OID also warns homeowners to verify settlement messages through official OID and State Farm contacts and not to give sensitive information to unsolicited callers. Your outreach will land next to scam calls about this same settlement. Make it obvious who you are, and never ask for a policy or claim number in a text.

    Which leads in your CRM match the settlement?

    Pull Oklahoma estimates from 2021 through 2025 where the lost reason or notes mention State Farm and a denial, a partial payment, or damage under the deductible. Those are the closest matches. Most CRMs store this in free-text notes, so search for terms like denied, deductible, State Farm, adjuster and claim.

    Our JobNimbus dead-lead export guide walks through building that list and cleaning it. The same segmenting logic sits underneath our roofing database reactivation playbook. This play adds a dated trigger on top of it.

    Segmenting Oklahoma roofing leads against the State Farm settlement
    Lead status in your CRMLikely in the program?Recommended action
    State Farm wind/hail claim denied, date of loss 2021 to 2025Likely, if the claim was closed without paymentWave one: informational text, offer a documented re-inspection
    State Farm claim partly paid, homeowner passed on your estimatePossibly; OID counts partial paymentsWave one, same message
    State Farm claim judged under the deductiblePossibly; named in the definitionWave one, same message
    Claim settled, went to judgment or withdrawnNo, excludedStandard unsold-estimate follow-up only
    Different carrier, or property outside OklahomaNoStandard unsold-estimate follow-up only
    Opted out, or no record of consent to textsNot relevantDo not text

    Your notes are not the claim file. You will not know for certain which homeowners qualify, and you should not tell anyone they do. The table sorts who hears from you first. It doesn't decide eligibility.

    What can a roofer say without crossing into adjusting?

    You can tell a homeowner the program exists, point them to the OID, and offer to re-inspect the roof and document its condition. A 2010 OID bulletin on roofing contractors says a roofer "must be licensed as a public adjuster in order to negotiate and act as an intermediary" between the insured and the insurer.

    The same bulletin says a contractor may recommend that the homeowner file a claim and may provide a repair estimate the homeowner submits. It lists as adjuster activity: advocating for the insured, helping prepare or file the claim, and advertising as a claim adjuster. Its advice is that "roofing contractors should act only as contractors and stay out of claim negotiation." The bulletin is from 2010, so confirm it still reflects current OID practice before you build a script on it.

    • Do say the OID announced a review program for some State Farm roof claims closed without payment between 2021 and 2025.
    • Do send them to the OID's settlement page and State Farm's notice for eligibility questions.
    • Do offer a dated re-inspection and a written estimate they can choose to submit.
    • Don't tell anyone they qualify or that State Farm will pay.
    • Don't fill out the opt-in form, call the administrator for them, or argue the claim.
    • Don't discuss whether they should opt in or sue. That is a question for their attorney.

    Sample text for wave one: "Hi [first name], it's [your name] at [company]. We looked at your roof after the [year] storm. Oklahoma announced a review of some State Farm roof claims closed without payment from 2021 to 2025. Details are on the Oklahoma Insurance Department's site. If you want a fresh inspection report, reply YES. Reply STOP to opt out." Keep it about that short.

    This is general information, not legal or insurance advice. Have your attorney review the script before the first send.

    How do you contact these homeowners compliantly?

    Treat the text as marketing and check consent before anything goes out. Under 47 CFR 64.1200, telephone solicitations to residential subscribers are barred before 8 a.m. or after 9 p.m. in the called party's local time. A request to revoke consent must be honored within a reasonable time not to exceed ten business days.

    Some of these leads date back to 2021. Whether a 2021 inspection request covered marketing texts depends on the form the homeowner signed and how you stored it. Our TCPA guide to texting old leads covers the consent question in detail. Where consent is unclear, a mailed letter is the safer channel.

    If you already ran our ACV follow-up play on the same estimates, don't stack a second campaign on top of it within a few weeks. Pick the trigger that fits each homeowner and send one message.

    What can this list realistically produce?

    Count replies before revenue. We've found reactivation campaigns produce a 2% to 5% response rate. On 300 Oklahoma State Farm estimates, that's roughly 6 to 15 replies. Some will want a re-inspection. Fewer will see a payment, and the review sets the amount, not you. Treat those figures as an estimate.

    The timing works for an off-season shop. Notices go out before year-end, and the 180-day opt-in window runs into 2027. If your office doesn't have the hours to build and send the list, our lead reactivation service starts from the same cleaned estimate export.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    How much is the State Farm Oklahoma roof settlement?

    The Oklahoma Insurance Department lists $47.86 million in total: $35 million for consumer restitution, $10 million for Strengthen Oklahoma Homes and $2.86 million in fines and exam expenses. The settlement agreement lets the restitution fund grow if claims need more. State Farm disputes the department's findings.

    Which claims does the State Farm settlement cover?

    Oklahoma residential wind and hail roof claims with a date of loss from January 1, 2021 through December 31, 2025 that were closed without payment. Per the OID, that includes partial payments and claims found to be under the deductible. Claims already settled, decided in court or withdrawn are excluded.

    Can a roofer file the opt-in for a homeowner?

    Don't. A 2010 OID bulletin says helping prepare or file a claim and acting as an intermediary is public adjuster work that needs a license. You can give the homeowner an inspection report or estimate to submit themselves.

    When is the opt-in deadline?

    The agreement gives homeowners 180 days from State Farm's initial notice, which must go out before December 31, 2026. Each notice states the deadline that applies. Check the OID's page for updates before quoting a date.

    Is this legal or insurance advice?

    No. This is general information. Eligibility depends on the claim file, and your outreach depends on the consent you hold. Send homeowners to the OID and their attorney, and ask your own attorney to review your scripts.

    Keep reading

    RoofingRoof Insurance Is Shifting Toward ACV: The Follow-Up Play for Your Old EstimatesFannie Mae and Freddie Mac now accept actual cash value coverage on roofs. Here is which old roofing estimates to pull, what to say, and what to leave out.RoofingHow to Pull Your Dead Roofing Leads Out of JobNimbusA step-by-step guide to building a JobNimbus report of unsold estimates and lost jobs, exporting it, cleaning it, and getting it ready for a reactivation campaign.Database ReactivationWhat Is a Dead Lead? Aging Windows and When an Old Lead Is Still Worth TextingWhat makes a sales lead dead, how cold, unsold and dormant leads differ, and which old leads in a contractor's CRM are still worth a text.